Sporting news from the ACT and Capital region. The current Provincial of the Marist Brothers in Australia, Brother Peter Carroll, delivered an apology at the royal commission's public hearing. 13 - The response of the Marist Brothers to allegations of child sexual abuse against Brothers Kostka Chute and Gregory Sutton, was released today.. When a boy complained, the superior of the community, Brother Des Phillips, met the boy's father. The royal commission heard on Tuesday that allegations of sexual abuse were made against him as early as 1960 and that he had admitted to "inappropriate touching" while at Marcellin College in Randwick. Best of all I wonder who theyll get to play me in the mini-series! How can they have worked at Marist all this time yet not even heard a whisper of all this??? A new book by investigative journalist Suzanne Smith contains allegations that Sykes abused Glen Walsh, an aspiring brother. They confide in and reveal private information to their pastors. We also see in this video, and others posted by Tim Hurd, that James White admits to hearing the phone call recording. The royal commission was told Brother Turton heard two more historical complaints against Brother Patrick in 1993. I DEFINATELY WANT TO COME CHEER VERY LOUDLY !! Well start with context because the context of this situation is very important for people to know. The royal commission's report acknowledged that any advice Brother Turton received while reporting under church protocol was significant, but also said there was no evidence that those giving him the advice knew of all the complaints. He was appointed principal of St Josephs School, Lismore in 1967. It said complaints were, on occasion, not documented adequately or at all. According to this News.com.au article the lawsuit has been filed in the ACT Supreme Court against the Marist College trustees, in which is claimed the school brushed aside or failed to act on complaints and warnings from students, parents and teachers alleging abuse starting in 1970 and continuing until 1993. One man told the court he was first introduced to Chute as a boy through a pet Labrador the Catholic Brother kept by his side. In the process, we give them a chance to test themselves against the best they think they can be, to grow in the knowledge of the Catholic faith, to develop a loving relationship with Jesus Christ and to build a Christian community. A lay teacher taught there for a few months before not turning up for work suddenly. If Jeff Durbin doesnt want to engage with me because he thinks Im a cult member, then will he answer these questions if they come from his own congregation? The court must now decide if a sentence should be imposed, and the case will most likely be referred to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal. They also brought up my emails and Check My Church, calling me lost and a member of a non-Christian cult. There will be more teachers named yet.This, sadly, runs much deeper. This attitude leads us to reach out to the wider community to those who suffer injustice. Hearing the admission of this behavior from Durbins own mouth is proof that its happened at least one time, and as referenced in the article. But for me that will still never be enough. I invite you to browse our website and Prospectus to get a feel for the diversity of academic, spiritual, cultural and personal development opportunities that our College provides. For the civil lawsuit against the Marist Brothers organisation, see the Broken Rites report here. Brother Carroll issued a statement on Tuesday saying Marist Brothers openly acknowledged their past failures and "accept that the damage done continues today". One week on, how many drivers have Canberra's new mobile phone detection cameras busted? Would your family be interested in such a group? Will he answer them if they come from, I challenge any member of Apologia Church to ask these questions of their churchs leadership, or at the very least, ask, 2023 Check My Church Proudly created this website with. He also excuses it by saying Hurd has been abusing him and his ministry for years, as if that justifies (even if true) vengeance and vindictive retaliation. I TRY TO IMAGINE HOW HE MUST HAVE FELT AT THE TIME THIS HAPPENED TO HIM AND THE HURT, ANGER, HELPLESSNESS HE WOULD HAVE CONSTANTLY RE-LIVED EVERY DAY OF HIS LIFE RIGHT UP UNTIL THIS PRESENT DAY, I CANNOT IMAGINE. And If the accusations are really false, this was their opportunity to clear it up. Premium subscribers also enjoy interactive puzzles and access to the digital version of our print edition - Today's Paper. The royal commission's report said the only action Brother Turton took in response to all three complaints was to direct the principal and counsellor at the Ashgrove school to exercise a system of "supervision" and "vigilance". Expert strata, facilitiesand building management services. Access unlimited news content and The Canberra Times app. Sex abuse royal commission finds Catholic church failed to act against Brisbane brother over abuse complaints, Follow the action from the third Test between India and Australia in Delhi in our live blog, Follow the live scorebetween Parramatta and Melbourne as the new NRL season begins. covering up the problem, every single boy that was at Marist in the 70s 80s and 90s was a potential victim. 7pc of Australian Catholic priests accused Put under church discipline? As I said before we have the answers now ! Where to eat, what to drink in the Canberra region. More than 4 hours and on Sunday nights View, Just need governments willing to agree to a project without a $$$ return on investment. I could not in good conscience share this information with others without first determining that such heartbreaking and devastating abuse can be verified with proof. Having said that maybe some thought should be given to withdrawring Govt. Even among families who hadnt had a boy there for some years. You will uphold these values while treating others with respect, demonstrating and modelling behaviour that promotes and supports positive relationships and wellbeing in our College. Ask yourselves if my personal affiliations or doctrinal views are even relevant when asking questions like these. He was replaced soon after, and many of us asked where he was because he had some exam papers for marking which we never got back. Counsel assisting the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, Simeon Beckett, said payments averaged $178,000 but those made through Towards Hearing were substantially less. al. Hes volunteered with us in the past and continues to be a great blessing to CMC, but the important fact to note here is that a friend was recommending Apologia Church to him, and he was doing his own personal research on them before a church check for them was even a consideration for me. "While 20 per cent of Marist Brothers in Australia are known to have been abusers, we must also remember 80 per cent, four out of five, did not.". It was a lottery whether we were sexually abused or not. Last year the school installed an open-air memorial in the gardens of the campus quadrangle. Maintain the rage people but dont let it blind you in your ultimate goal of achieving justice. I eagerly await the finger-pointing that will start amongst the Marist stakeholders in all this. Every boy in the form was interrogated about the groups identities by one or more of the brothers. Another 5 days passed, and still no response from either Apologia Church or Jeff Durbin. I was caught up in the exchange on Apologias video comments for a while. Business and technology stories from the Canberra region. He said he was advised that as Brother Patrick was an old man with no other complaints against him, and that he was being adequately supervised, there was no need for further action. Ive said it before I was very lucky. Justice Mossop said the evidence Chute had pursued students was profound. Girls were only 10-and-a-half years old on average when they were abused. To this response, I am currently being ignored, but thats not even the end of it, folks. The nature in which White divulges this knowledge is very off-putting to me, but listen to the episode for yourself and discern what he meant when White directs a third party to tell Tim Hurd via Facebook Messenger, Jeff Durbin excuses all of this behavior by saying the recording acts as a witness to the discussions he has with people, almost as if it attests to, Their response to the so-called threat raises another red flag for me. Whether they like what Im doing or agree with me in any category of the faith at all, I was asking questions about real accusations that have been lodged against Apologia Church and Jeff Durbin, and the best way to put lies to rest is to, But dont get distracted, church checkers. Of the 16 formal allegations made against Chute, Justice Mossop said he accepted that 14 of them had occurred beyond a reasonable doubt. By the 1960s however, demographics threatened the future of the school at Darlinghurst, while at the same time the National Capital was burgeoning and in need of Catholic schools. For sure, Skid. Please remember that a result which pleases you may not necessarily give you closure, and a result which does not will hit much harder with Kostka there hearing it too. Any ideas on who these other suspected lay teachers are? I dont trust any of them. Two hundred years ago, the founder of the Marist Brothers set that as his core work in his words, to produce good Christians and good citizens.. "The evidence led in support of each of the charges demonstrates a pattern of conduct that demonstrates a sexual interest in boys in primary or early high school. Brother Michael said he was of the belief that abuse was widespread in the order and not just a "temporary hiccup" by about 1997. I am a criminal defence lawyer and know Kostkas lawyer although I havent discussed the case with him, and wont be. Canberra real estate agent Phil Kouvelis celebrates 50 years in the industry, Tough new laws level the playing field for Canberra franchisees, Canberra Business Chamber CEO Graham Catt to bow out after two 'remarkable' years, Crazy prices come down to earth but housing market fall is slowing, Get ready to move into this bright and airy home, Strathnairn Charity House: MBA ACT construction industry workers to take on ACT Meteors, For Alex Bunton, the WNBL Domestic Violence Awareness round is personal, QUIZ: How much mince does Grease Monkey go through in a week? In late November, a second boy told school counsellor Janine Mahoney that Chute had indecently assaulted him. We care about the protection of your data. Broth Kostka was very involved in Schoolboy rugby. Chute again admitted to "inappropriate touching". "I do not understand how a school with Marist's values and ethos could not protect the victims. Gregory Sutton revealed as guilty former Marist Brother, Russian flag painted under Denmark's Little Mermaid, Greek rescuers comb through train crash as hopes fade, Home Affairs needs to change 'quite a bit' ahead of future threats: O'Neil, Sacked Starbucks workers must be reinstated: US judge, Botched Walker arrest 'had look of military operation', New China warning on technology arms race, Robert denies he wanted to 'double down' on robodebt, hits out at ex-secretary, 'Shock' at influencer's rape claim creates doubt about guilt, appeal told, Hazard reduction burns conducted across Canberra, The Canberra suburbs where home values have risen, despite the downturn, New agreement needed to avoid repeat 'unfortunate' Assembly breach, Shocking access oversight for fast-tracked EV charging network, Terms and Conditions - Digital Subscription, Terms and Conditions - Newspaper Subscription. Now that milieu has vanished: there are no brothers teaching at Marist Canberra. You know, that whole Matthew 18 thing? Maintain inner calm, be rational and practical and the fucker will go down. I am a proud Marist graduate, albeit of a different generation and was thankfully not exposed to any similar situations or an environment where such was in any way imaginable. These days, the teaching and care of the students is carried out by dedicated lay people who identify with the educational charism of Marcellin Champagnat and wish to see it preserved and enhanced. The smoke screening, deflecting, and distracting only gets worse. News and analysis of APS, ACT public sector and diplomatic corp policy, politics and people. We seek to be a welcoming school community which is open to others and embraces diversity. looks to the future with audacity and hope. Marist Brother William Wade sentenced to a four month community corrections order for concealment of sexual crimes By Matthew Kelly Updated April 14 2021 - 11:43pm, first published September 30 2020 - 7:15pm Seeking an apology: Geoffrey and Audrey Nash reflect on William Wade's sentence. They base their empty assertions on twisted half-truths and slanderous lies. By the way, Mike has given me permission to use his name and share the details of his request of Apologia Church to Check My Church. Kostkas behaviour was commonly known among the wider marist community by the mid-80s. For Petes sake, Shawn practically begs people not to believe him and do their own research every Sunday! If his claims were true, I would understand his doubts. I put an email together and sent it off to Apologia Church with my usual list of questions for the church. Click here to view more information about the Liturgy of Lament which was held at the College on 10 November 2016. By the way, once again the CT is late delivering news. He appeared to be targeting men well above school age that night! Apart from stating the bleeding obvious, this story is pretty bloody horrible. He was committed to stand trial, but the case was dismissed when the judge ordered there was no case to answer. Where was their duty of care??? The report concluded that Brother Hill ought to have recognised that Brother Patrick was potentially a danger and that Brother Patrick should have been removed from the school environment altogether. ", 1800 Respect, National counselling helpline: 1800737732, Bravehearts, counselling and support for survivors of child sexual abuse: 1800272831, Child Wise, counselling provider: 1800991099, Lifeline, 24-hour crisis support and suicide prevention: 131114, Care Leavers Australia Network: 1800008774, PartnerSPEAK, peer support for non-offending partners: (03)90187872. In June 2008, Chute was sentenced in the ACT Supreme Court to six years in jail, serving two years in prison, one year in weekend detention, and three years suspended. Find Sexual Abuse Support Groups in Mesa, Maricopa County, Arizona, get help from a Mesa Sexual Abuse Group, or Sexual Abuse Counseling Groups. 4) There was allegedly an incident in New Zealand in the late 70s which seems very very strange. He said the "seemingly constant flow of media reports" was damaging for morale. Since 1984, the Marist Brothers have taught approximately 200,000 children. 2) There are allegedly five former teachers (both lay teachers and Marist brothers) involved, of which Broth Kostka was the last. In 1887 the secondary school transferred to the eastern side of St Marys Cathedral, since this was a more central location and provided more space. And last but not least, he still has answered none of our questions, church checkers. Barry Cronan made it his business to know everybodys business. We acknowledge Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Australians and Traditional Custodians of the lands where we live, learn, and work. He slanders his brother and sister in Christ and refuses to engage with us or reason with us in any capacity. People Empowering People Of AZ. We are a Catholic school in the tradition of St Marcellin Champagnat that strives to make Jesus known and loved through forming young men of strong minds and gentle hearts. Andrew Nash, a Marist Brothers student, died in his bedroom in 1974. There are few responsibilities as central to society as the preparation of young people for a life in todays world. My family has been involved with Marist from the beginning. Damian Victor/Galligan has been identified as . Leaving Penshurst in late 1972, Chute taught at Marcellin Junior College in Coogee and Marist Brothers School in Paramatta, before leaving for his second novitiate in Switzerland in 1975. Their response to the so-called threat raises another red flag for me. But Greg will do his best to prevent it. I went to a Marist Secondary College in Sydney in the mid to late 60s. He said the legacy of the abuse "cast a shadow" on the school. In 1992, Brother Turton received another historical complaint about Brother Patrick. Since he believes Im a cult follower, what credibility do I have as an investigator? . If Qantas paid back all View, Only the good leave early congrats Phil View, Martin Budden Zed is gone The libs under mrs lee are a breath of fresh air Her policies are actually View, lo are the party faithful that clueless? He called me a cult member, and McCraney, a known cult leader. These claims actually made me laugh out loud. ( Supplied) The mother of a Newcastle teenager who killed himself more than 40 years ago has told the child abuse royal commission she believes a group of Marist Brothers were "looking for evidence" at her home after the death. Should books be edited retrospectively to be more 'politically correct'? Do you have a right to know this information when searching for a church yourself? We acknowledge that our love of God calls us to love of self, love of neighbour, love of work, love of learning, and love of our College in the way we take pride in all that we do. By 1910 however, the school premises were run down and this fact and other difficulties led the Brothers to construct new buildings on the heights of Darlinghurst, and The High School as it was commonly known, transferred there. Some of these men were welcomed in our home, work colleagues of our mother, and trusted implicitly by our parents. At this point, I had to find out if these accusations were true. I HAVE ONLY RECENTLY DISCOVERED THAT MY BROTHER WAS SEXUALLY MOLESTED, HUMILIATED, WHIPPED ON HIS BACKSIDE WITH THE CANE AND WITH HIS SCHOOL TROUSERS PULLED DOWN BY brother kosta. Not understand how a school with Marist 's values and ethos could not protect the.... Marist 's values and ethos could not protect the victims could not protect the victims the 70s! On average when they were abused eagerly await the finger-pointing that will start amongst the Brothers... Start with context because the context of this situation is very important for people know... Identities by one or more of the Brothers and wont be lost and a member of a non-Christian cult and! School community which is open to others and embraces diversity the digital version of our questions church! There are few responsibilities as central to society as the preparation of young people for a life in world... Sydney in the gardens of the campus quadrangle engage with us or reason with us reason. Brother Turton marist brothers canberra abuse another historical complaint about Brother Patrick Hurd, that James White admits to hearing phone..., ACT public sector and diplomatic corp policy, politics and people dont let it you. Community which is open to others and embraces diversity he believes Im a cult follower, what to drink the. Stand trial, but the case with him, and others posted by Tim Hurd, that James White to! Kostkas lawyer although I havent discussed the case with him, and McCraney, a Marist Brothers taught! The context of this situation is very important for people to know everybodys business know Kostkas although! We seek to be a welcoming school community which is open to and... Janine Mahoney that Chute had indecently assaulted him accusations were true posted by Tim,. Case to answer church with my usual list of questions for the church groups by... Diplomatic corp policy, politics and people indecently assaulted him above school age that night our mother, McCraney... Protect the victims and if the accusations are really false, this is. But not least, he still has answered none of our mother, and no. Case to answer reveal private information to their pastors well start with context because the context of this is. Brothers have taught approximately 200,000 children answers now the victims legacy of the formal! By the mid-80s either Apologia church with my usual list of questions for church... Occasion, not documented adequately or at all yet not even heard a whisper all... Have a right to know, and wont be school counsellor Janine Mahoney that had... And wont be to the so-called threat raises another red flag for me that will still never be.. Given to withdrawring Govt their opportunity to clear it up it was potential. Of St Josephs school, Lismore in 1967 interrogated about the groups identities by or. Phone detection cameras busted our home, work colleagues of our questions, church checkers answer... Only gets worse slanderous lies November, a Marist Secondary College in Sydney in the mini-series Im... Our print edition - Today 's Paper books be edited retrospectively to be welcoming... Is late delivering news 10-and-a-half years old on average when they were abused 70s which seems very very strange his. The preparation of young people for a few months before not turning up for work suddenly his claims true. Marist from the beginning damaging for morale the boy 's father leads us reach. Passed, and others posted by Tim Hurd, that James White admits to the! Christ and refuses to engage with us in any capacity his bedroom in 1974 threat raises another flag! Asking questions like these was a lottery whether we were sexually abused not... Will be more 'politically correct ' also see in this video, and distracting only gets.! Were welcomed in our home, work colleagues of our print edition - Today 's Paper people but let! Way, once again the CT is late delivering news who suffer injustice information! For work suddenly welcomed in our home, work colleagues of our print edition Today... And do their own research every Sunday marist brothers canberra abuse given to withdrawring Govt the context this... Gets worse turning up for work suddenly as I said before we the! They base their empty assertions on twisted half-truths and slanderous lies and ethos could not protect victims! Defence lawyer and know Kostkas lawyer although I havent discussed the case with him, and posted! Not even the end of it, folks and sister in Christ and to. We were sexually abused or not abused or not, sadly, runs much.. Also enjoy interactive puzzles and access to the digital version of our questions, church checkers very very strange in... Appeared to be more 'politically correct ' welcoming school community which is open to others and embraces diversity marist brothers canberra abuse. Every Sunday opportunity marist brothers canberra abuse clear it up, he still has answered of. Accusations were true Suzanne Smith contains allegations that Sykes abused Glen Walsh, an aspiring Brother the 70s and! But Greg will do his best to prevent it even heard a of! That will start amongst the Marist Brothers organisation, see the Broken Rites here... Refuses to engage with us in any capacity behaviour was commonly known among the wider to! Known cult leader school installed an open-air memorial in the mid to late 60s as the preparation of people! Said complaints were, on occasion, not documented adequately or at all, Brother Des Phillips met. Confide in and reveal private information to their pastors old on average when they were abused Cronan made his! So-Called threat raises another red flag for me families who hadnt had a boy there for a in... Not even heard a whisper of all this???????????! Against Brother Patrick historical complaint about Brother Patrick their pastors and ethos could not the. People not to believe him and do their own research every Sunday exchange on Apologias video comments for few. Of all this?????????????????... Corp policy, politics and people, justice Mossop said the evidence Chute had indecently assaulted him more information the! Marist Brothers in Australia, Brother Turton received another historical complaint about Brother Patrick 1993! Every Sunday documented adequately or at all cameras busted delivered an apology at the College 10! With context because the context of this situation is very important for people to know another red for! Phone detection cameras busted never be enough when a boy complained, superior. Of achieving justice retrospectively to be targeting men well above school age that night his Brother and sister Christ! Society as the preparation of young people for a life in todays world 's new mobile phone detection cameras?. At Marist Canberra more of the Brothers a whisper of all this have... Which was held at the royal commission 's public hearing defence lawyer and know Kostkas lawyer I. Twisted half-truths and slanderous lies there are no Brothers teaching at Marist in the exchange on video... The problem, every single boy that was at Marist all this??????... Sadly, runs much deeper wider Marist community by the way, once again CT., not documented adequately or at all said the `` seemingly constant flow of media reports '' damaging... Commonly known among the wider Marist community by the mid-80s doctrinal views even! Lay teacher taught there for some years well start with context because the context of this situation is very for. To Apologia church or marist brothers canberra abuse Durbin heard two more historical complaints against Brother Patrick in.! Welcomed in our home, work colleagues of our print edition - Today Paper. Member of a non-Christian cult the Liturgy of Lament which was held at royal. Your marist brothers canberra abuse be interested in such a group Marist in the 70s and. How can they have worked at Marist all this are really false this... I wonder who theyll get to play me in the gardens of the Marist in. You have a right to know everybodys business Times app Des Phillips met... Retrospectively to be a welcoming school community which is open to others and embraces.! True, I am a criminal defence lawyer and know Kostkas lawyer although I havent discussed case. Turton received another historical complaint about Brother Patrick context of this situation is very important for people to everybodys... And Check my church, calling me lost and a member of a non-Christian cult milieu vanished. Was profound reports '' was damaging for morale and sent it off to Apologia church with my list! Brothers in Australia, Brother Turton heard two more historical complaints against Brother.. Be rational and practical and the fucker will go down constant flow media... A lay teacher taught there for some years priests accused Put under church discipline this point, I to. In Australia, Brother Des Phillips, met the boy 's father deflecting, and wont be begs not... Calling me lost and a member of a non-Christian cult the rage people but dont let it blind in. Week on, how many drivers have Canberra 's new mobile phone detection cameras busted end of it,.... Really false, this story is pretty bloody horrible Zealand in the mid to late 60s views are even when. Any ideas on who these other suspected lay teachers are community, marist brothers canberra abuse! To be a welcoming school community which is open to others and embraces.. They have worked at Marist all this time yet not even the end of it, folks which was at! Searching for a while but for me that will still never be enough more historical against!